Climb the Ecommerce Personalization Ladder in 2025: From Basic Recognition to Predictive Service

Jul 15

Think about the last time you fired up Netflix and found a show you loved without even searching. That’s great personalization in action. Now think about those creepy ads that follow you around the web for weeks after you bought a simple floor lamp. One makes you feel understood; the other makes you feel stalked. Which side of that line is your ecommerce experience on? In 2025, shoppers won’t tolerate irrelevant, impersonal marketing – in fact, 71% of consumers expect personalized interactions and 76% get frustrated when they don’t get them mckinsey.com. For mid-market ecommerce businesses, personalization is the ace up your sleeve. You might not out-spend Amazon, but you can out-personalize them. Done right, ecommerce personalization can drive double-digit gains in revenue and loyalty (often a 10–15% revenue lift on average mckinsey.com) – all while delighting customers with experiences tailored just for them.

Personalization isn’t just a B2C concern, either. B2B ecommerce personalization is increasingly critical as well. Industrial buyers and corporate procurement managers now expect the same relevant, personalized ecommerce experiences they get as consumers at home. Whether you’re B2B or direct-to-consumer, delivering the right experience to the right customer at the right time is the key to improve ecommerce conversion rate, boost average order values, and build long-term loyalty.

In this article, we’ll walk through the five-step personalization ladder – from basic recognition to proactive, predictive service. At each step, you’ll learn what it is, a quick win to implement, the key KPI to watch, and example tools or platforms that can help (think Adobe Commerce personalization features, Shopify, BigCommerce, dotdigital personalization, AI and more). We’ll also look at real case studies (like Azio Beauty, MSC Industrial, and Rural King) proving the ROI of these tactics. Finally, we’ll cover a five-question litmus test to keep your personalization efforts on the right side of “helpful” versus “creepy.” Let’s climb!

Why Personalization Still Wins in 2025

Personalization in ecommerce isn’t a new concept, but in 2025 it’s more important than ever. Consumers have been trained by Netflix, Amazon, and others to expect relevance at every turn. If you’re showing every visitor the same content or making every buyer the same generic offer, you’re leaving money on the table. Consider that personalization leaders (often digital-native brands) drive significantly more revenue growth than their peers mckinsey.com. Even a mid-sized online retailer can see immediate lifts by tailoring the experience:

Higher conversion and sales: Showing customers content and products that matter to them increases the chance they’ll buy. One recent industry analysis found that personalization most often drives a 10-15% increase in revenue for companies that get it right mckinsey.com. Even simple tactics like personalized product recommendations can boost revenue by triple digits in some cases.
Larger average order value: Relevant cross-sells and upsells mean bigger baskets. Many brands find their average order value climbs about 10% or more when they implement solid personalization (e.g. “complete the look” suggestions or tailored bundles).
Better repeat purchase rates: Personalization keeps customers engaged and coming back. Brands using personalized emails, reminders, and offers see higher repeat purchase rates (often 15%+ improvements) as shoppers feel the brand gets them and caters to their needs.
Lower support burden: When the experience is smooth and proactive, support tickets go down. For example, proactively communicating (or even preemptively fixing) issues can cut customer complaints – some firms see support tickets drop by ~8% after rolling out personalization improvements.

In short, personalization is a conversion rate optimization strategy and a customer experience strategy rolled into one. It’s about relevance. And in a world where your customers can switch to a competitor with a click, relevance wins. So how do you get there without crossing into “too much” territory? By climbing the personalization ladder step by step.

The Five-Step Ecommerce Personalization Ladder

Improving your personalization isn’t an overnight project – it’s a progression. I like to think of it as a five-level ladder. Each rung represents a deeper level of personalized experience you can offer: Recognition, Contextual Merchandising, Journey Orchestration, Predictive AI Bundling, and Proactive Service. Most mid-market brands today are stuck on the first or second rung. By climbing just one rung higher, you can often unlock more growth than pouring the same budget into getting new traffic. Let’s break down each level and how you can implement it.

Level 1: Recognition (Basic Personalization)

What it is: At its most basic, personalization starts with recognition. This means acknowledging the customer as an individual. It could be as simple as greeting a returning shopper by name on your site or in an email. It includes showing basic info relevant to them, such as the last product they viewed (“Welcome back, Jane! Still interested in Product X?”) or displaying their account status. It’s the digital equivalent of a store clerk saying, “Hi [Name], welcome back!” instead of just “Hello, customer.”

Quick Win: If you have an email or SMS marketing platform, turn on merge tags for names and relevant info in your communications. For instance, use the customer’s first name in subject lines or SMS greetings to grab attention. Many tools like Mailchimp, Klaviyo, or Dotdigital make this easy. On your ecommerce site, you can implement simple recognition by showing a “Recently viewed” section or a “Welcome back, [Name]” banner when a known user logs in. These small touches instantly make the experience feel more personal without heavy lifting. (Bonus: ensure your transactional emails (order confirmations, etc.) address the customer by name and maybe highlight their last purchase or a related item).

Key KPI: Email open and click-through rates. At this foundational level, one of the best measures of success is whether customers engage more when you use basic personalization. Track your email open rates and CTRs for campaigns where you insert the customer’s name or other personal tokens. Personalized subject lines, for example, can significantly lift open ratesinstapage.com. If your customers won’t even open your emails or acknowledge your messages, deeper personalization won’t matter. Aim for an email open rate above ~30% for your house list and a click-through rate north of 3-5% – if you’re below those, work on recognition tactics to improve relevance and trust.

Example Tools: Most ecommerce platforms and ESPs (Email Service Providers) have built-in support for this basic personalization. For example, Adobe Commerce (Magento) and Shopify both allow customer greeting messages on the homepage when logged in. Email tools like Dotdigital or Klaviyo let you insert dynamic first names and product recommendations with minimal effort. Level 1 doesn’t usually require any fancy AI – just a smart use of the data you already have (like the customer’s name, login status, and browsing history).

Level 2: Contextual Merchandising

What it is: Level 2 moves from “Hi [Name]” to actually adjusting product offerings based on context. This is where personalized product recommendations, upsells and cross-sells come in. Think “People like you also bought…” or “Complete the look” bundles on a fashion site. Essentially, you’re using what you know (from browsing or purchase history, or behaviors of similar customers) to suggest something relevant to the shopper’s current context. If they’re looking at a laptop, you show a laptop bag or an accessory. If they just added a drill to cart, you suggest drill bits or safety glasses before checkout.

Quick Win: Turn on your platform’s native recommendation engine. Many ecommerce platforms have basic recommendation features available out-of-the-box or via an app/extension. For example, Shopify and BigCommerce allow “related product” blocks that you can configure on product pages or in the cart. Adobe Commerce personalization features (powered by Adobe Sensei AI) can automatically display “customers also viewed” or “bought together” suggestions if you enable them. If your platform doesn’t have a built-in solution, consider a third-party app (like Nosto, Klevu, or Recolize) that plugs in personalized recommendations. Even a simple “Top picks for you” carousel based on browsing history can be a quick win to implement.

Key KPI: Upsell and cross-sell conversion rate, and by extension your average order value (AOV). To measure success, look at what percentage of customers take a recommended product and add it to their cart or purchase it. For instance, if 100 customers see a “Complete the look” suggestion and 5 of them add the suggested item, that’s a 5% conversion on the recommendation – a solid start. Also track AOV: is it increasing after you add contextual merchandising? A good goal is a 5-10% lift in AOV from personalized upsells. If your baseline AOV was $100, can you get it to $110 by suggesting relevant add-ons? That’s the kind of lift you’re looking for. Over time, aim for at least 5% of orders including an upsell item that was suggested, indicating customers find your recommendations helpful (and not just noise).

Example Tools: Ecommerce AI personalization is often at play by this stage. Adobe Sensei (for Adobe Commerce) uses machine learning on your catalog and shopper data to make smart recommendations. Shopify has introduced AI-driven recommendations as well (often through apps or the built-in Shopify Magic features). BigCommerce offers integrations with tools like Feedonomics and Searchspring that can personalize product listings bigcommerce.com. If you use a marketing automation platform like Dotdigital or Klaviyo, you can also incorporate product recs into emails (“You might also like…” in a post-purchase email, for example). The key is to use whatever you have available to dynamically suggest products instead of showing static, one-size-fits-all content.

Level 3: Journey Orchestration

What it is: At level 3, personalization becomes coordinated across channels. It’s not just on-site product suggestions or isolated personalized emails – it’s making every touchpoint work in concert based on the customer’s journey. Journey orchestration means if a customer left an item in their cart, the email they get, the SMS reminder you send, and even the hero banner when they return to your site all sing the same tune (“Your cart is waiting – complete your purchase of Product X”). Similarly, if they just purchased something, maybe your next email offers a how-to guide for that product, and your site highlights complementary accessories on the homepage. The experience feels seamless and consistent. In essence, you’re orchestrating the timing and messaging across channels (email, SMS, on-site, even ads) so that the customer always sees content that fits where they are in their shopping journey.

Quick Win: Break down the silos between your systems. Start by integrating your ecommerce platform with your email/SMS marketing platform and any CRM or advertising tools you use. A customer data platform (CDP) or a tool like Dotdigital can help by syncing customer segments and events across channels. For example, if you use Dotdigital with Adobe Commerce or Shopify, ensure that when a customer browses a product or abandons a cart, that data triggers the appropriate email or text. Even without a fancy CDP, you can set up triggered flows: an abandoned cart email series, a browse abandonment trigger (e.g. “Still thinking about that item?”), or a post-purchase sequence that references exactly what the customer bought. The quick win here is to connect the data – make sure the right hand (marketing) knows what the left hand (website/shop) is doing. If you haven’t already, implement an abandoned cart recovery email (that’s low-hanging fruit that orchestrates the journey from on-site to email and can greatly improve conversion rates). Then extend that concept: ensure your Facebook/Google ads retargeting is showing the exact product someone viewed, not just a generic ad. Consistency is key.

Key KPI: Time to repeat purchase (repeat purchase rate within a given time frame). Why this metric? Because well-orchestrated customer journeys should shorten the time between purchases and increase customer lifetime value. If a new customer usually takes 90 days before buying again, a coordinated approach might bring that down to 60 days by gently nudging through multiple channels. Track the percentage of first-time customers who make a second purchase within 30, 60, or 90 days. As you implement journey orchestration, you want that percentage to go up, meaning people are coming back sooner. For instance, measure a cohort of customers who bought this month – what % buy again within two months? If you can raise that by a few percentage points via coordinated follow-ups, that’s a clear win. Also watch engagement across channels: open rates, SMS click-throughs, site return visits – these are leading indicators that your multi-channel messages are resonating.

Example Tools: Dotdigital personalization features are built for this kind of orchestration – it can act as a hub, pulling in ecommerce data and pushing out segmented messages via email, SMS, etc. Other CDPs like Segment, or marketing clouds like Klaviyo, HubSpot, or Salesforce Marketing Cloud can fulfill similar roles. On a simpler level, even just using Shopify’s built-in automations or BigCommerce’s email integrations to send consistent messages is a start. The goal is a single customer view and connected systems. If you’re an omnichannel retailer with physical stores, consider integrating your POS data too – e.g., if someone buys in store, your email system should know not to keep pushing the item they already purchased. Journey orchestration is where many mid-market companies start seeing the need for a more unified tech stack (or an agency partner) to help connect the dots.

Level 4: Predictive AI Bundling

What it is: Now we’re getting into the really exciting stuff. Level 4 uses machine learning and AI to predict customer needs and bundle offers proactively. This goes beyond reacting to what a customer did (viewed X, bought Y) and into forecasting what they will want. Examples: a skincare site predicting when you’ll likely run out of the moisturizer you bought and emailing you before you run out with a one-click reorder link. Or a B2B supply distributor predicting when a client will need to restock certain materials based on their usage patterns and suggesting a bundle or subscription. It’s personalized timing and bundling driven by algorithms. Often this takes the form of subscription offers, replenishment reminders, or “next best product” suggestions generated by AI analysis of customer behavior and similar customers.

Quick Win: Leverage an AI-driven personalization tool on a small scale to prove it out. For instance, Adobe Commerce users can tap into Adobe Sensei which has AI product recommendation and bundling capabilities. Shopify merchants might experiment with apps that do predictive recommendations (Shopify has been rolling out more AI features recently, sometimes referred to as Shopify’s AI or personalization tools in Shopify Plus). BigCommerce has partnerships (like with Feedonomics or Klevu AI) that can help create bundles or recommendations based on data. If you want a lightweight approach, consider starting with one replenishable SKU or category. Set up a workflow: after a set time post-purchase, use AI to predict if the customer might be running low. Tools like Relo (for Shopify) do exactly this – they analyze each customer’s purchase timing and product usage to send a tailored reorder reminder. In fact, Azio Beauty (case study below) did this with great success. The key quick win: start small. Pick a product people buy repeatedly (pet food, skincare, printer ink, etc.) and pilot an AI-driven replenishment email or subscription prompt. Measure results, then expand to more products.

Key KPI: Subscription or auto-reorder opt-in rate. Since Level 4 is often about getting customers into a proactive repurchase cadence, you want to track how many customers take you up on those predictive offers. For example, if you send out “It’s time to reorder” emails, what percentage of customers click and complete the purchase? Or what percentage sign up for a subscription program (if you offer “subscribe and save”)? A good starting benchmark might be aiming for an 8-12% opt-in on a well-timed replenishment offer for a replenishable product. In other words, out of 100 customers who bought a product, getting 8-12 of them to either reorder via your prompt or subscribe for auto-delivery within a couple of months. This shows that your predictive timing is on point. Over time, this drives predictable revenue and higher lifetime value, as customers don’t drift away and forget to re-purchase. Another KPI here could be repeat purchase rate for those specific products – does the AI intervention lift the overall repeats?

Example Tools: This is the realm of ecommerce AI personalization engines. Adobe Sensei (within Adobe Commerce) is a prime example, using AI to suggest products and bundles. Shopify’s ecosystem includes solutions like Rebuy or Relo for replenishment, and Shopify’s own AI features are evolving. BigCommerce merchants might use tools like Klevu (AI search and recommendations) or feed management with intelligent rules to predict trends bigcommerce.com. Customer Data Platforms with AI, like Optimove or Lexer, can crunch data to predict churn or next product to buy. The beauty is you don’t need to build AI from scratch – many of these tools plug into your store and start learning from your order history. At Level 4, you’re essentially delegating some personalization decisions to algorithms that can find patterns (e.g., “Customers who bought protein powder usually need a refill in 30 days”). The result is highly personalized, timely offers that feel like magic to the customer (“Wow, they reminded me just when I needed this!”).

Level 5: Proactive Service

What it is: The pinnacle of the personalization ladder is proactive customer service – going beyond selling and actually anticipating customer service needs before the customer contacts you. This level isn’t about marketing or sales prompts, it’s about building trust and delight through service. Imagine: A customer’s order is delayed in transit due to a shipping issue. Instead of waiting for the customer to get frustrated and email support, your system automatically detects the delay and sends an apology and proactively sends out a replacement or a discount for the inconvenience, without the customer asking. Or a B2B example: a regular client hasn’t ordered their usual supply this month – your account rep reaches out to check if they’d like to reorder or had any issues, before the client even notices they’re low. Proactive service uses the data and triggers available to solve problems preemptively. It shows customers “we’ve got your back.”

Quick Win: Set up automated alerts for common friction points in the customer experience, and an action to go with each. A classic one is shipping delays: most ecommerce platforms or shipping software can ping you (via webhook or integration) if an order hasn’t shipped by a certain time or is stuck in transit beyond the expected delivery date. Use a tool like Zapier or Make (Integromat) to catch those events. For example, if an order is marked as delayed or there’s no tracking update for, say, 5 days, automatically trigger an email to the customer: “We noticed a possible delay with your order and are on it.” Even better, if cost allows, proactively ship a replacement or offer a coupon before they ask. Another quick win area is product issues – say you sell tech gadgets and a certain batch had a defect; proactively email purchasers of that batch with a fix or offer. Essentially, brainstorm “what might go wrong?” and then use your data to catch it early. Start with one scenario (shipping delay is a great first use case) and script out a proactive response.

Key KPI: Negative review rate or customer satisfaction score. Since proactive service is about preventing disappointment, measure how often customers still end up unhappy. Track your negative review rate (1-star and 2-star reviews as a percentage of total reviews) or, if you have customer satisfaction surveys/Net Promoter Score, track those. The goal is to see a decrease in complaints and negative feedback after implementing proactive service initiatives. For instance, if normally 5% of customers leave a negative review citing “shipping took too long” or “item arrived damaged and no one helped,” after proactive steps maybe that drops to 2%. Another indicator: the volume of “Where is my order?” support tickets should go down because you’re addressing the issue before the customer feels the need to contact you. A good target might be cutting your negative reviews in half over a few months of proactive outreach. When customers do follow up with support, you might also see improved sentiment – they’re pleasantly surprised the company reached out first.

Example Tools: Beyond Zapier/Make for automation, many platforms have specific solutions: for example, Shopify Flow (for Shopify Plus users) can automate actions based on order events. There are also specialized customer service platforms (like Gladly or Zendesk) that can use triggers to send proactive messages. Some shipping platforms (like Narvar or AfterShip) offer proactive tracking alerts you can customize. If you’re pulling data into a central place (even just a Google Sheet via API), you can have your team or an automation watch for anomalies. The tools aren’t as important as the strategy: it’s about being attentive and using your data. At Level 5, you might also integrate directly with your fulfillment partners – for instance, have your warehouse system alert you if a certain product’s shipments are getting delayed, then pause related marketing for those customers and send a proactive apology. This level truly separates the customer-centric leaders from the rest, and it becomes a competitive moat – customers remember that kind of above-and-beyond care.

Bottom line: Very few companies, especially at the mid-market level, have fully mastered Level 5. If you can reach this stage, you’ll not only drive sales but also foster deep loyalty. However, you don’t need to be at Level 5 immediately to see benefits – each rung up the ladder can yield tangible ROI. In fact, climbing from Level 1 to Level 2, or Level 2 to 3, often boosts revenue faster than pouring the same budget into more ad spend or traffic. Next, let’s look at some real-world proof of what climbing the ladder can do.

Case Studies: Personalization in Action (ROI Examples)

It’s always motivating to see how these personalization strategies play out in real businesses. Here are three real-life examples – spanning DTC, B2B, and omnichannel retail – that show the impact of climbing the personalization ladder:

Azio Beauty (DTC skincare brand): Azio Beauty wanted to increase repeat purchases for its skincare products. By climbing from basic personalization up to a predictive AI bundling approach (Level 4), they nailed it. They plugged in a predictive reorder engine (using an app called Relo on their Shopify store) that analyzes each customer’s buying patterns and product usage. The system would predict when a customer was likely running low on, say, a face serum, and automatically send a replenishment email at just the right time. Crucially, that email included a “magic cart” – a pre-loaded cart with the exact item (and even complementary add-ons) so the customer could reorder in one click. The result? Azio saw an 18% increase in repeat orders and a whopping 30× ROI on that personalization initiative reloapp.co. In other words, for every $1 they spent on the tool and effort, they got $30 back. It became their top-performing email flow, driving significant revenue from existing customers reloapp.co. This showcases the power of Level 4 personalization: predictive, well-timed offers that feel helpful (not pushy) can dramatically boost loyalty and lifetime value.
MSC Industrial Supply (B2B industrial distributor): Personalization isn’t just for shiny consumer brands – it’s a game-changer in B2B as well. MSC Industrial, a $3 billion distributor of industrial supplies, transformed its call center into a sales powerhouse by implementing a personalization system (Level 2-3 on our ladder, focusing on contextual recommendations and orchestrated data) for their phone reps. They replaced a legacy sales intel tool with an AI-driven platform (Proton AI) that, during customer calls, surfaces personalized product recommendations: due-for-reorder items, gaps in the customer’s usual spend (“wallet-share” opportunities), and relevant add-ons in real time for the rep to mention proton.ai. So if a customer regularly buys drilling equipment, the system might prompt the rep: “This customer hasn’t bought safety gloves yet and often similar clients do – suggest it.” The impact was dramatic. MSC saw about a 20× growth in upsell/cross-sell revenue after switching to the AI personalization system proton.ai, turning their previously reactive call center into a proactive sales channel. Reps achieved roughly a 13% conversion rate on the AI-suggested recommendations and generated an extra ~$15,000 in upsell revenue per rep per year proton.ai. Those numbers mean the recommendations were both relevant and valuable – customers actually bought the suggested items frequently, and it added up to millions in new revenue. This case shows that even in B2B, suggesting the right product at the right time (with AI help) is far more effective than generic sales pitches.
Rural King (Omnichannel farm & home retailer): Rural King operates both online and brick-and-mortar stores, and they found a clever way to blend the two with personalized service. They focused on Level 3 (Journey Orchestration) and a bit of Level 5 by personalizing the post-purchase experience for buy-online, pick-up in-store customers. Here’s what they did: when a customer placed an order online for in-store pickup, Rural King would send an SMS message to that customer before they arrived at the store. The text wasn’t just “Your order is ready”; it also included a helpful usage guide or tips related to the product they bought, plus a suggestion of an add-on item available in-store. For example, if you bought a new power tool for pickup, you might get a text: “Your power drill is ready for pickup! BTW, here’s a 2-minute how-to video on getting started, and don’t forget the right drill bits – we set some aside for you. Just ask when you arrive!” Customers loved this value-added nudge. The result: those personalized pickup texts with usage guides actually lifted in-store basket size by around 12%. Shoppers who received the message often added extra items to their purchase when they came in, thanks to the useful reminder and the feeling that Rural King was looking out for them. It’s a great example of orchestrating online and offline channels with a personal touch, and of being proactive in a non-intrusive way (the info is genuinely helpful, not just a pure sales push).

These case studies prove that climbing the personalization ladder translates to real dollars. Whether it’s a DTC brand boosting repeat sales with AI timing, a B2B supplier increasing average spend through intelligent suggestions, or an omnichannel retailer blending service and marketing to grow basket size – the common thread is delivering relevance and value. When customers feel like you truly understand their needs (sometimes even before they do!), they reward you with more business.

Avoid the “Creepy” Factor: The 5-Question Personalization Litmus Test

Before you run off and implement every personalization idea under the sun, let’s address the elephant in the room: privacy and the “creepiness” factor. Personalization is powerful, but if you cross the line into using data in ways that feel invasive or overly personal, you can lose customer trust fast. How do you make sure your personalized experiences come off as helpful and not stalker-ish? Use this five-question litmus test as a guardrail for any personalized campaign or feature you plan:

Would I say this aloud to the customer face-to-face? – This is a gut-check. If your personalization involves messaging that would feel awkward saying in person, it might be too much. (For example, telling a customer “We noticed you looked at X and didn’t buy it – why not?” would be creepy in person, so it’s likely creepy via email too.)
Does it use only data the customer knowingly gave us? – Great personalization can be done with data the customer has shared or would expect you to have (their purchase history, browsing on your site, preferences they told you, etc.). The moment you rely on info they didn’t explicitly give (like third-party tracking that feels out-of-the-blue), you risk freaking them out. Stick to data the customer would assume you have in the normal relationship.
Will the message/content likely surprise (or unsettle) them? – Surprise can be good in marketing, but not when it comes to revealing how much you know about someone. Your goal is to make the customer feel understood, not exposed. If a personalization tactic might make someone think “How did they know THAT about me?!”, consider dialing it back. Personalize just enough to be useful, not so much that it’s uncanny.
Does it comply with all relevant privacy laws and preferences? – This is non-negotiable. Ensure your use of customer data aligns with GDPR, CCPA, and any other regional privacy regulations that apply. Also, honor customers’ communication preferences and consent. If they opted out of tracking or emails, don’t sneak personalization in through another channel. Legal compliance is the bare minimum; going beyond that to make customers comfortable is even better.
Does it add real value for the customer? – Perhaps the most important question. Every personalization effort should pass the “so what?” test from the customer’s perspective. Are you doing this to genuinely improve their experience or just because you can? Useful recommendations, timely reminders, and helpful content add value. Simply calling someone by name or referencing a detail without benefit can come off as hollow or intrusive. If it doesn’t tangibly help the customer, reconsider doing it.

If your idea fails any of these questions, rethink it or throttle it back. It’s better to err on the side of being slightly less personalized than to venture into creepy territory that erodes trust. A pro tip: implement easy opt-outs for personalized content (like a global “unsubscribe me from all recommendations” link) for those who are sensitive, and always provide clear privacy notices about how you use data. In an age of high privacy awareness, transparency is key. Remember, the goal is to use personalization to build relationships and loyalty – not to appear as Big Brother in your customer’s life.

Tailoring Your Personalization Strategy (B2B vs. B2C)

Every business is different. You might be reading this thinking, “This all sounds great, but where do I start?” The answer can depend on your business model. Here are some quick pointers to align the personalization ladder to your situation:

If you’re a B2B company with eCommerce as a “side-car” to sales reps: Focus on Level 2 (Contextual Merchandising) early, because this can empower not just your website but your sales team (as MSC Industrial’s case showed). Equip your reps with data-driven product suggestions for cross-selling, and use your eCommerce site to reinforce those suggestions (like a “recommended for you” section when logged in). Over time, build up through Level 3 by integrating your CRM or sales data with marketing emails – ensure that after a sales call, the follow-up email is personalized with what was discussed. You might not jump straight to AI predictive stuff on day one, but you can gradually layer that in (Level 4) to help predict reorders. B2B buyers value efficiency and insight; personalization can provide both.
If you’re an omnichannel retailer (online + physical stores): Level 3 (Journey Orchestration) is mandatory for you. Customers hop between your site and store, so your personalization must connect those dots. Invest in a unified customer database that merges in-store purchases and online behavior. For example, if a customer buys something in a store, your email system should know it and maybe send a personalized thank-you with tips for that product. Or use geolocation personalization: send an SMS with a special offer when a loyalty customer walks near your store. Also, proactive service (Level 5) is crucial in omnichannel – if a store is out of stock on an item for a buy-online-pickup, proactively offer to ship it or find it at another location before the customer is disappointed. The key is seamless experience across channels; your personalization should make the customer feel known whether they’re on your website, app, or talking to an associate in-store.
If you’re a pure-play digital brand (DTC or online-only B2B): You have no excuse not to be pushing the top of the ladder! Your competitors are likely already utilizing AI and advanced personalization. Aim to get to Level 4 (Predictive AI) as soon as possible if you haven’t yet – this will give you an edge in retention and lifetime value. Level 5 (Proactive Service) can become your secret weapon: for an online-only business, proactive customer support (like reaching out if you see someone having an issue on the site, or immediately following up a purchase with a personal check-in) can set you apart from larger players who often have impersonal service. Essentially, a pure digital business should try to operate like a high-touch boutique – using all the data at hand to treat each customer uniquely. If you’re still at basic “Hi [Name]” personalization and nothing more, plan to implement at least journey orchestration and one predictive use case in the next quarter. The market will leave you behind if you don’t.

Wherever you’re starting, the advice is the same: pick one rung and climb up. You don’t have to do everything at once. Maybe your first step is implementing that personalized product recommendation block on your homepage (Level 2). Maybe it’s connecting your email and SMS campaigns with a unified message (Level 3). Get a quick win, prove the ROI, then move to the next level. Personalization is a journey, not a checkbox.

Conclusion: Start Climbing Today

Personalization is no longer optional in 2025 – it’s the price of entry for winning customer loyalty and driving higher conversion in ecommerce. The good news is that by climbing this ladder one step at a time, you can steadily transform your customer experience and see measurable results at each stage. Every rung you climb – from recognizing your customer by name all the way to predicting their needs before they voice them – will improve your metrics: you’ll improve ecommerce conversion rates, boost repeat sales, raise average order values, and strengthen customer satisfaction.

The key is to take action now. Don’t get overwhelmed thinking you need a massive overhaul or the latest AI buzzword implementation overnight. Look at where you are on the personalization ladder today, and commit to climbing one rung higher in the next 30 days. Maybe that means finally setting up those abandoned cart emails, or turning on a product recommendations engine, or integrating a simple AI tool for one product line. A small step can yield a big win – and once you see that win, it’ll fuel your momentum to tackle the next level.

At Creatuity, we’ve seen firsthand how mid-market ecommerce brands can leapfrog competitors by leveraging personalization effectively. We challenge you to be one of those success stories. Audit your customer experience today and identify one area to personalize more. Climb that next rung. Your future revenue growth — and your customers — will thank you for it.

Ready to accelerate your climb up the personalization ladder? Let’s talk. Creatuity’s ecommerce experts (yes, including Joshua Warren himself) are here to brainstorm personalized strategies tailored to your business. We’ll help you identify the quickest wins and craft a roadmap to truly personalized commerce. Book a free ecommerce brainstorming session with our team – just click the “Let’s Talk” button on our site and schedule a chat. Take that step, and let’s start turning your one-size-fits-all site into a conversion-driving, personalized experience powerhouse. Your customers are waiting for that “Netflix-like” experience – and we’re ready to help you deliver it. Let’s climb together, one rung at a time. reloapp.co proton.ai

Citations

The value of getting personalization right—or wrong—is multiplying | McKinsey

https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/growth-marketing-and-sales/our-insights/the-value-of-getting-personalization-right-or-wrong-is-multiplying

The value of getting personalization right—or wrong—is multiplying | McKinsey

https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/growth-marketing-and-sales/our-insights/the-value-of-getting-personalization-right-or-wrong-is-multiplying

70 Personalization Statistics Every Marketer Should Know in 2025

https://instapage.com/blog/personalization-statistics/

Reach new levels of productivity and growth with BigAI. - BigCommerce

https://www.bigcommerce.com/next-big-thing/ai-for-commerce/

Reach new levels of productivity and growth with BigAI. - BigCommerce

https://www.bigcommerce.com/next-big-thing/ai-for-commerce/

Feedonomics Integrations | BigCommerce